As negotiations at the International Maritime Organization (IMO) enter a decisive phase next week, the debate around the Net-Zero Framework (NZF) has become increasingly polarized and a wave of misleading narratives threatens to stall progress.
Certain industry voices and countries at the IMO have labeled the NZF as a “radical” or “expensive” proposal, painting it as an obligatory tax that will destroy economies and exorbitantly increase shipping costs. Yet, when stripped of political rhetoric and thoroughly examined through economic and environmental analyses, the NZF — combining a global GHG Fuel Intensity (GFI) standard with a targeted economic pricing mechanism — emerges as the most practical, predictable and effective measure to decarbonize global trade.
In this blog, we will address some narratives about the NZF, from cost to feasibility.
Will the NZF cripple the industry and hurt developing economies?
One of the loudest talking points from opposing member states is that binding climate rules will harm shipowners and disrupt supply chains. In truth, cost estimations show that the extraordinary scale and efficiency of modern ships limit the price impacts to pennies on the dollar of most goods.
That’s why major shipping associations and fuel producers have repeatedly voiced support for a unified IMO framework. Adopting a meaningful standard at the IMO will make regional and national measures less likely and less needed to address shipping’s climate impact.
Detractors have circulated alarming cost estimates of the NZF, framing it as an added burden on the shipping industry, businesses and consumers. But assessments like these treat the status quo as “free,” overlooking the billions spent on fossil fuels and the costs of continued dependence on volatile oil markets.
In reality, recent fossil fuel price shocks have increased the cost of shipping and goods far more than estimates of the NZF’s impacts. In a recent article for Splash, Gavin Allwright, secretary-general of the International Windship Association, documents how the shipping industry has spent $95 billion more on fuel since the Hormuz crisis began.
But what would have happened if that money had been invested in free, zero-emission wind propulsion instead of burning it in volatile oil markets? Alwright argues that shipowners could already be saving billions while securing greater energy independence in the long-term.
Keep this in mind as we head into the IMO meetings. Negotiators are opposing the proposed $11-$12 billion fund for the NZF on the basis of cost yet are handing over nearly eight times that amount to fossil fuel suppliers since February 2026 with no uproar.
But it’s not just the exorbitant and volatile cost of fossil fuels that we need to factor in. Climate change and environmental pollution are not only deadly, they are also expensive.
Opportunity Green noted that recent research suggests earlier estimates of climate change costs were underestimated by a factor of three to five. These studies are relatively conservative in comparing the implementation of the NZF and the costs resulting from the climate crisis. By 2050, Opportunity Green found that the total economic impacts of climate change are protected to far exceed the costs of implementing the framework; that gap widens by 2050.
A rapidly warming world, where disasters already hit hardest and most often in the Global South, is not free. The costs will only continue to rise.
A full accounting should also consider the health care costs, elevated cancer risks and premature deaths associated with ship pollution, especially in communities near ports. Leaving this toll out makes the status quo look cheaper than it is.
Who will pay for shipping’s energy transition?
Without the NZF in place, consumers will bear the cost of climate change and short-term planning within the cost of their delivered goods. As recent months have shown, the price spikes and volatility of fossil fuel markets will ultimately hurt consumers. This trend will only continue to get worse in a warming world where climate disasters are more likely to impact logistics and shipping/port operations.
Instead, the NZF’s Net Zero Fund provides resources to alleviate price impacts for essential goods and food products. As written, it could raise revenues around $10 billion a year to provide targeted support for countries negatively impacted by costs and climate disasters.
If just transition guides equitable redistribution of these funds to climate-vulnerable countries, it would be a notable move toward implementing the “polluter pays” principle without leaving any country behind, particularly in the transition to a sustainable shipping economy. Though notably, it is still far less than what climate-vulnerable countries advocated for, which was a more ambitious fund that would raise $40 billion to $60 billion annually.
Do the fuels and technology exist to meet the targets?
The technology exists, and what is needed now is supply and demand signals. Continued delay on zero and near-zero emission fuel (ZNZ) production is caused by the delay of the NZF itself, leading to regulatory uncertainty and industry hedging. This has created a classic “chicken-and-egg” scenario where producers are waiting for demand and shipowners waiting for supply and low prices.
Critics often argue that mandating lower fuel intensity puts the cart before the horse because ZNZs are not yet available on a global scale. This ignores how energy transitions work in practice.
Energy developers will not build multi-billion-dollar green hydrogen or ammonia facilities without guaranteed buyers, and shipowners will not order dual-fuel vessels without guaranteed fuel supply. The NZF breaks this “chicken-and-egg” deadlock through a phased, realistic trajectory:
- Gradual ramp-up: The GFI standard starts with achievable reductions (targeting a 20%-30% cut in emissions by 2030, scaling to 70%-80% by 2040) rather than an overnight mandate.
- Built-in flexibility: Vessels that cannot yet access green fuels can comply by purchasing remedial units, while early movers running on clean fuels can earn and trade surplus compliance units — directly subsidizing the cost gap for pioneers.
The technology, financing and a comprehensive plan are all there. What we need now is long-term thinking and political will. As we head into the next set of meetings, Pacific Environment urges delegates, decisionmakers and attendees to adopt the most meaningful measure that has been put on the table over the last year of delay, the NZF, and move the industry toward effective action. Further delay or watering down the framework, now, would be the costliest option of all.
Every year of delay locks in more fossil-fueled vessels, deepens regulatory fragmentation and increases the eventual cost of transition. By pairing a clear fuel standard with a smart economic engine, the IMO NZF offers something rare in global climate policy: a practical, unified roadmap that turns ambition into an investable reality.
Want to learn more about what our team is up to at the IMO meetings? Follow along on our dedicated IMO Hub.